OwnedFor
Back to search

MacBook·laptop

MacBook Pro 16 M1 Max

Marketing claims50
Community reality87

Based on 38 credible posts from Hacker News. 5 filtered out as bot-like or off-topic.

Medium confidenceA solid sample; expect small shifts as more owners post. How we score

Scored November 11, 2026

Check price on Amazon

We may earn a commission from this link. It never affects the score.

Owner reviews

Overall owner mood

63% positive (24)26% mixed (10)11% negative (4)

Most owners are happy with it: 63% of 38 reviews are positive and 11% negative. Praise centers on price & value and controls & input. The most common complaint is sound (2 owners). Owners are divided on performance. Owners with 6+ months of use are more positive (100%), which suggests it holds up well.

What owners like

  • Price & value praised by 3 owners (1 disagree)

    “For an easy start just install LM Studio and have a play.) I picked up a second-hand 64GB M1 Max MacBook Pro a while back for not too much money for such experimentation.”

  • Controls & input praised by 2 owners (1 disagree)

    “I’ve been dabbling in Ableton Live Suite 12 Lite, which came with my Native Instruments Komplete Kontrol S88 MKII midi keyboard, and this machine never breaks a sweat.”

What owners complain about

  • Sound raised by 2 owners

    “these are just the bugs i can think of off the top of my head which have existed for literal years: - on iphone, the haptic and sound feedback from tapping letters on the keyboard has a noticeable lag to it half the time.”

Owners are split on

  • Performance 3 like it · 5 don't

Worth reading the reviews on these if they matter to you.

What owners talk about

  • Performance3 praise · 5 complain
  • Price & value3 praise · 1 complain
  • Controls & input2 praise · 1 complain
  • Battery & charging1 praise · 1 complain
  • Sound0 praise · 2 complain
  • Build & durability1 praise · 1 complain
  • Display1 praise · 1 complain

Built from the reviews themselves — every quote links to the owner who wrote it.

The claims, and the evidence

What the brand claims

No published claims on file for this product yet.

What owners report

  • “[...] That said, I enjoy the hardware improvements happening, because it allowed me to go from that huge full tower desktop with multiple GPUs and water cooling to doing everything I need in my life, pretty much, from a 14" M1 Max Macbook Pro. [...] For me, I am not quite ready to replace my M1 Max MBP with an M4, but I am likely going to bump to an M5, simply for performance when editing photos in Lightroom / DxO Photo Lab, but that's more of a recent requirement. Before I got this M1 Max MBP, I had a 2015 15" MBP that worked just fine for 7 years, and would have kept going if it didn't have a bulging battery and I decided to upgrade rather than repair it. [...]”

    after 2 yearsView on Hacker News
  • “Having been all over the apple range over the years, the M1 Max Macbook Pro i'm currently using has been I would say the best of their laptops since the original G4 Powerbook. A couple of years into ownership of this machine, and it's been an excellent experience. I develop on it every day, and i've no need to upgrade it, so i'll wait for the M4 :)”

    after 2 yearsView on Hacker News
  • “I think that is much too hand-wavy regarding the performance differences. [...] I would wager that, for many applications, only a subset of these tasks are relevant to the performance of the application, yet such benchmark suites distil out all nuance into a single value. [...] I have tried running CASTEP (built from source), a density functional theory calculator, on both an M1 Max MacBook Pro [0], and on a Ryzen 7840HS Lenovo laptop [1]. A cursory glance at those Geekbench results linked might make you expect that the performance is roughly equivalent, but the Ryzen outperforms the Mac by about 4x, a huge difference. [...] Presumably the Ryzen's balance of instruction performance is more useful for DFT calculations than the Mac's, which perhaps is weaker in areas that might matter for this application, but stronger in areas that might matter for others. [...]”

  • “I have an M1 Max Macbook Pro, and having used many employer's newer variants of M-series macbook's since then, I'm still very satisfied with my M1 Max but the air series is really good, and very light my M1 is now noticeably heavy and I don't think upgrading to another Macbook Pro is the move the resell value of the M1 did not hold, specifically the bumped up storage models. There doesn't seem to be a market for 8TB of space specifically, but the base 1 - 2TB holds its value because the baseline of the MBP holds its value M5 Max looks tempting if there is a very compelling tradein, but the M1 Max is pretty old so I don't have real hope of that, but I'll look. [...]”

Read all 38 owner reviews

Common MacBook Pro 16 M1 Max problems

Problems most owners who mention them agree on, plus ones owners are split on.

  • PerformanceOwners split: 5 complain, 3 happy

    “Chiming in here, M1 Max MacBook Pro 64GB using gpt-oss:20b over ollama with Visual Studio Code with GitHub Copilot is unusably slow compared to using Claude Sonnet 4, which requires (I think?) GitHub Copilot Pro.”

    View on Hacker News
  • Sound2 owners report this

    “If I do the five finger gesture on my M1 Max Macbook Pro, and start typing, the first few keystrokes will give me the "you're trying to type where you can't" sound and they won't register into the search box.”

    View on Hacker News

Compare

See the best laptops, ranked by owners →