OwnedFor
Back to search

Apple·headphones

AirPods Max

Marketing claims55
Community reality69

Based on 67 credible posts from Hacker News, Bluesky & YouTube. 21 filtered out as bot-like or off-topic.

High confidenceA large sample of owners; this score is stable. How we score

Scored September 27, 2026

Check price on Amazon

We may earn a commission from this link. It never affects the score.

Owner reviews

Overall owner mood

46% positive (31)31% mixed (21)22% negative (15)

Owners are split: 46% of 67 reviews are positive, 22% negative, and the rest mixed or neutral. Praise centers on sound and comfort & size. The most common complaint is price & value (10 owners). Owners with 6+ months of use feel about the same (50% positive).

What owners like

  • Sound praised by 9 owners

    “For those at home, there are any number of audiophile headphones that beat it for sound and price.”

  • Comfort & size praised by 9 owners

    “The Apple AirPod Max sound great, bur are heavy and fairly uncomfortable on the head when worn for more than an hour or two.”

  • Noise cancelling praised by 5 owners

    “And the noise cancelling and transparency mode are absolutely phenomenal.”

  • Controls & input praised by 2 owners

    “I've been enjoying the nothing headphones, I enjoy having an off button and ability to connect via wire to the device.”

What owners complain about

  • Price & value raised by 10 owners

    “Ya, expensive but I won’t buy another pair for years.”

  • Sound raised by 5 owners

    “I had the xm6 but the combination of worse sound (for me at least) and shallow earcups which hurt my ears drove me back to the product”

  • Build & durability raised by 5 owners

    “My the product 1 left a headband dent in my skull from how poor the quality of the headband was after more than a year of daily use.”

  • Comfort & size raised by 4 owners

    “While they are very comfortable, the ear caps are a pain to clean.”

What owners talk about

  • Sound9 praise · 5 complain
  • Price & value4 praise · 10 complain
  • Comfort & size9 praise · 4 complain
  • Noise cancelling5 praise · 4 complain
  • Battery & charging3 praise · 4 complain
  • Build & durability0 praise · 5 complain
  • Software & AI1 praise · 4 complain
  • Connectivity1 praise · 3 complain

Built from the reviews themselves — every quote links to the owner who wrote it.

AirPods Max long-term: how it holds up

Long-term owners feel about the same as new ones, so the AirPods Max holds up.

  • First months50% recommend · 4 owners
  • 1 year or more50% recommend · 8 owners

When problems show up

  • Software & AItypically around 3 years · 2 reports

The claims, and the evidence

What the brand claims

  • Active Noise Cancellation with Transparency modeMixedNoise cancelling: 5 of 9 positive
  • Computational audio with Adaptive EQMixedSound: 9 of 14 positive
  • Personalized Spatial AudioMixedSound: 9 of 14 positive
  • Apple-designed 40mm dynamic driverMixedSound: 9 of 14 positive
  • Digital Crown for precise controlMixedControls & input: 2 of 3 positive
  • Up to 20 hours of listening time with Active Noise CancellationMixedBattery & charging: 3 of 7 positive
  • USB-C chargingMixedBattery & charging: 3 of 7 positive

What owners report

  • “The AirPods Max are the most comfortable headphones I've ever worn. [...] The battery is still healthy five years later. [...]”

    after 5 yearsView on Hacker News
  • “I’ve been using AirPods Max since they first launched, and over the years I’ve tried several times to switch to Bose. However, the Bose headphones just haven’t worked as smoothly for me from a software and integration standpoint. I tend to run into more glitches and small issues compared to the AirPods Max. [...]”

    after 3 yearsView on Hacker News
  • “I bought the original AirPods Max when they came out a few years ago. They hurt my ears if I wear them for more than an hour or so and the software is garbage - constantly losing one channel or just failing to connect at all - to Apple devices. Apple has not done enough to fix glitchy software problems, which continue to occur even on the latest AirPods Pro devices. I won’t touch the Max headphones until I start hearing that the software has been fixed.”

    after 3 yearsView on Hacker News
  • “My AirPods Max 1 left a headband dent in my skull from how poor the quality of the headband was after more than a year of daily use. You should get checked out. No adult should have a dent put in their skull by headphones.”

Read all 67 owner reviews

Common AirPods Max problems

Issues at least two owners independently report.

  • Price & value10 mentions

    “I wore my original beloved AirPods Max for a walk one Edmonton winter day and they became a brick. I found out quickly that it’s a well known design flaw with internal moisture build up, exacerbated by fluctuations in temperature. Did they fix this known flaw that has ruined hundreds of people’s very expensive headphones? [...]”

    View on Hacker News
  • Build & durability5 mentions

    “I wore my original beloved AirPods Max for a walk one Edmonton winter day and they became a brick. I found out quickly that it’s a well known design flaw with internal moisture build up, exacerbated by fluctuations in temperature. Did they fix this known flaw that has ruined hundreds of people’s very expensive headphones? [...]”

    View on Hacker News
  • Software & AI4 mentions

    “I bought the original AirPods Max when they came out a few years ago. They hurt my ears if I wear them for more than an hour or so and the software is garbage - constantly losing one channel or just failing to connect at all - to Apple devices. Apple has not done enough to fix glitchy software problems, which continue to occur even on the latest AirPods Pro devices. I won’t touch the Max headphones until I start hearing that the software has been fixed.”

    View on Hacker News
  • Battery & charging4 mentions

    “Yup, my Airpods Max don't hold a charge anymore. Right on time for me to buy the shiny new one!”

    View on Hacker News
  • Connectivity3 mentions

    “The Original Airpods Max had terrible connectivity. The bluetooth would break down for days, and all instructions on the internet would tell you needed to remove the device and re-add it. [...] So, if Apple keeps on building new features while not fixing major problems, I'm not considering buying these unreliable, expensive products at all ...”

    View on Hacker News
  • Sound5 mentions

    “ok i bought the bose qc ultra gen 2 a few months ago telling myself i was done being an audiophile but im sorry they just do not sound good and EQ cannot fix it i should’ve just bought the airpods max or sennheiser momentums 😭”

    View on Bluesky

Compare

See the best headphones & earbuds, ranked by owners →